For small business owners operating as an S Corporation, the end of the fiscal year can bring a mix of anticipation and stress. While S Corps enjoy unique tax advantages, such as pass-through taxation, preparing for year-end tax filing can be challenging, especially if you’re not aware of common pitfalls. Missing critical items could lead to IRS penalties or unnecessary complications, which is the last thing any business owner wants to deal with.

To help ensure your S Corporation is fully prepared for tax filing season, we’ve rounded up some of the most frequently missed items. Read on to get a head start on your year-end checklist and avoid any tax-related surprises.

1. Properly Tracking Shareholder Salaries and Distributions

One of the most common issues for S Corps is failing to distinguish between shareholder salaries (or reasonable compensation) and distributions. Since an S Corporation’s income “passes through” to its shareholders, the IRS emphasizes the importance of paying shareholders who actively work in the business a reasonable salary before taking distributions.

Why It Matters

• Salaries are subject to payroll taxes, while distributions are not.
• Misclassifying distributions as salaries (or vice versa) can trigger red flags with the IRS and lead to audits, penalties, or reclassification adjustments.

What to Do:

• Review payroll records and ensure shareholder salaries align with industry standards for the roles they perform.
• Consult your accountant or CPA if you’re unsure what constitutes “reasonable compensation” in your industry.

Pro Tip:

If cash flow has tightened this year, prioritize reasonable salaries to avoid regulatory scrutiny. Erratic or extremely low shareholder salaries could raise eyebrows with tax authorities.

2. Loan Documentation Between the Business and Shareholders

A common oversight for S Corporation owners is loaning (or borrowing) funds between the business and its shareholders without properly documenting the transaction. The IRS is known to scrutinize undocumented shareholder loans, as they could incorrectly classify such transactions as taxable income or disguised distributions.

Why It Matters

• Undocumented loans may appear to the IRS as taxable income or distributions for shareholders.
• Poorly documented loans can lead to double taxation if adjustments become necessary.

What to Do:

• Create formal loan agreements for any funds borrowed or lent by the corporation. Specify repayment terms, interest rates, and schedules.
• Keep a meticulous record of repayments and outstanding balances.

Pro Tip:

Work with a financial professional to draft proper loan agreements and ensure they meet IRS standards to avoid misclassification or penalties.

3. Accurately Allocating Business Expenses

Many S Corporation owners unintentionally blur the lines between personal and business expenses, which can lead to compliance issues during tax filing. Expenses that benefit both the business and individual shareholders must be carefully documented and justified for tax deductions.

Why It Matters

• Misclassifying personal expenses as business expenses can disqualify the deduction and flag your return for audits.
• Failing to apply the proper allocation method could lead to underpaid taxes or overstated deductions.

What to Do:

• Separate personal and business expenses as rigorously as possible.
• Keep detailed receipts and documentation for any expense that could be subject to review. For example, if you operate a home office, maintain clear records of the work-related area and utility costs.

Pro Tip:

Invest in accounting software like QuickBooks to categorize and track expenses. Many platforms allow you to tag transactions and run reports specifically tailored for S Corps.

4. Double-Check Fringe Benefits Taxation (Shareholder-Employees)

If an S Corporation provides fringe benefits (such as health insurance, life insurance, or retirement contributions) to its shareholder-employees, it’s essential to correctly report these benefits for tax purposes. Fringe benefits are often neglected in tax planning, which can lead to errors that affect year-end filings.

Why It Matters

• Certain fringe benefits provided to more-than-2%-shareholder-employees are considered taxable income and must be included on their W-2s.
• Incorrect treatment of fringe benefits can lead to unintentional underreporting of income, increasing liability risks.

What to Do:

• Work with your payroll provider to ensure reports for taxable fringe benefits are accurate.
• Review IRS Publication 15-B, which outlines taxable vs. nontaxable benefits.

Pro Tip:

If your S Corp offers group health insurance, verify whether the health premiums were included in the taxable wages of shareholder-employees who hold more than a 2% interest.

5. Keeping Accurate Basis Tracking for Shareholders

Many S Corporation owners are unaware of how critical basis tracking is to their year-end tax filings. A shareholder’s basis in the corporation determines the taxability of distributions, losses, or deductions, and neglecting to maintain accurate records can cause significant issues.

Why It Matters

• Without accurate basis calculations, shareholders may inadvertently claim losses or deductions they’re not entitled to.
• Miscalculating basis can lead to overstatement of tax refunds or unexpected tax liabilities during audits.

What to Do:

• Maintain detailed documentation of each shareholder’s contributions to the company, distributions received, and share of pass-through earnings.
• Update basis calculations annually and ensure they’re accurately reported on Form 7203.

Pro Tip:

If you’re unsure how to calculate basis, consult with a tax professional to avoid errors. This is particularly important if your S Corporation operates at a loss or if shareholders have varied contributions and ownership stakes.

6. Filing the Correct Forms on Time

Timely filing of all necessary forms is fundamental to your S Corporation’s compliance. Beyond the obvious annual returns (Form 1120-S), S Corporations often overlook additional forms that may need completing based on their activities or tax elections.

Examples:

• Form 2553 – If you’re electing S Corporation status for the first time.
• Form 941 – For reporting quarterly payroll taxes.
• Forms W-2 and 1099-NEC – To report employee wages and payments to contractors.

Why It Matters

• Late filings can attract failure-to-file penalties and interest charges, compounding your overall tax burden.
• Omitting critical forms may result in your S Corporation being unable to retain its favorable tax status.

What to Do:

• Mark all major IRS filing deadlines for S Corporations on your calendar.
• Partner with a CPA who specializes in small businesses to review filing obligations, including state and local forms.

Pro Tip:

Double-check your payroll records around December to guarantee timely filing of W-2s and 1099s in January.

7. Avoiding Missteps on Estimated Taxes

Although S Corporations themselves don’t pay income tax (since profits pass through to the shareholders), failure to properly account for estimated taxes can create unintended consequences for the shareholders who report this income on their own returns.

Why It Matters

• Shareholders must make quarterly estimated payments based on their share of the company’s pass-through income.
• Failing to pay sufficient estimates may result in fines and penalties at the individual level.

What to Do:

• Work with a tax advisor to calculate each shareholder’s estimated tax liability and ensure payments are on track for the year.
• Revisit these estimates if your S Corp has experienced significant revenue or expense fluctuations.

Pro Tip:

Schedule regular meetings with shareholders to review estimated payments and discuss potential changes to their tax liabilities.

8. Leveraging Exclusive Deductions and Credits

Lastly, don’t leave money on the table—many S Corporations miss out on lucrative deductions or credits they’re entitled to claim. Examples include the Qualified Business Income (QBI) Deduction, Research and Development Tax Credits, and potential state-specific incentives.

Why It Matters

• Deductions like the QBI allow shareholders to reduce taxable income by up to 20%, potentially saving thousands of dollars.
• Overlooking credits can mean missing out on significant annual savings.

What to Do:

• Take the time to review your S Corporation’s eligibility for available deductions and credits.
• Consult with a tax expert to explore how federal and state incentives apply to your business.

Pro Tip:

Many deductions have time-sensitive eligibility requirements, so begin your review process as early as possible.

Final Thoughts

Year-end tax preparation for your S Corporation doesn’t have to be overwhelming. By addressing the frequently missed items outlined above, your business can stay compliant while maximizing its tax efficiency. Remember, preparation is key—proactively organizing payroll records, basis tracking, and reports will save you headaches (and potential penalties) come tax season.

If you’re feeling uncertain about any of these steps, working with a qualified CPA or tax advisor is an investment worth making. After all, your time is better spent focusing on what you do best—running and growing your S Corporation.

Want additional resources and support? Reach out to one of our small-business tax advisors today!

Schedule A Call